7

In a related question, I got entangled in a debate whether the word "here" (which I would classify readily as an adverb) is in reality a preposition. I am curious which modern analyses find syntactical similarities between "here" and words like "in, at, on, for, to" that they range them in the same category as well as the reasoning behind them.

Of course I am aware that many English prepositions are actually adverbs (i.e. they can stand on their own, without relation to a noun, and express for example a location on their own, e.g. "I am in").

Eleshar
  • 2,363
  • 15
  • 21
  • Can you point to any of the 'more modern analyses' that you mention? – Gaston Ümlaut Dec 20 '16 at 21:32
  • 1
    Actually that is the point of the question. So, no, I cannot, but I admit the question could be phrased better. – Eleshar Dec 20 '16 at 21:33
  • 3
    'Of course I am aware that many English prepositions are actually adverbs' Many linguists (e.g. Pullum) would say that these are not adverbs but intransitive prepositions. Unlike other adverbs, 'in' cannot appear freely in other parts of the clause, for one thing. One fact that favours treating 'here' as a P is that you can add 'right' in front of it (right here), which you can do for many other prepositions (right at, right on, right in) but not with other parts of speech (#right book, right eat, right red). – WavesWashSands Dec 20 '16 at 23:41
  • 2
    "Here" is a prepositional phrase (PP), since it can be conjoined with another PP: "I sleep here and in the kitchen". – Greg Lee Dec 21 '16 at 06:50
  • 1
    @Greg Lee: "I sleep soundly and in the kitchen". Does that make "soundly" a preposition? – mobileink Jan 03 '17 at 20:42
  • @mobileink, Well, by my reasoning, it would make "soundly" a PP. That is not a happy conclusion, so I agree that my argument needs work. – Greg Lee Jan 03 '17 at 21:45
  • The phrase I sleep soundly and in the kitchen does not sound grammatical to me, it should be imho I sleep soundly in the kitchen. 2) I am after word class of "here" and not sure PP, which is an IC syntax term, is really on the same level of terminology but PPs in general have similar distribution as adverbs - PPs of location will corresponds to location adverbs, PPs of time will correspond to temporal adverbs, PPs of mode correspond to regular adverbs (I do it correctly and I do it by the book).
  • – Eleshar Jan 04 '17 at 10:44